Sunday, 30 June 2013

Let My Himalayas Be:

I think I am a very bad person.

When the news of the Uttrakhand tragedy broke on Facebook, my instant comment on a friend’s post was “I am neither surprised nor sad". Over the days, with more stories surfacing on the massive scale of destruction and lives lost, not a single one could affect me greatly. Each time I read the news, a smug satisfaction filled me and I would silently say to myself; “Well done Nature, now they will understand why they shouldn’t mess up with you”.   

Last year in Oct, I had travelled through Rudraprayag and Chamoli to reach Lata village bordering the Nanda Devi Biosphere Reserve. The sheer mass of concrete all around, blasting of mountains for roads, hundreds of vehicles on roads, dust haze, plastic floating on the green rivers and construction of four dams in a 150km stretch had left me feeling devastated. (my earlier post on Uttrakhand)

I came back and spoke to a couple of NGOs, environmentalists and dug up stories in Down to Earth and what I found left me astounded, shattered and feeling utterly helpless.  Because it’s not just Uttrakhand which is leading the devastation, the entire Himalayan eco-system ranging from Himachal to Arunachal is at stake.

Information sourced from the citizens’ report - The Energy State and the Tragedy of its Rivers*

  • 200 tunnel-based hydroelectric power projects have been announced to achieve the target of generating 24,876 MW of electricity. The majority of these are to be built in Zone IV & V of this earthquake prone state where landslides and floods are very common. The 200 power projects envisage a construction of 700 km of tunnels that will be built through the eco-fragile mountains.
  •  Around 2 to 2.2 million people living in villages under which these tunnels pass are being affected. There was no Public Hearing before the construction of Singoli-Bhatwadi Hydroelectric Project (90 MW) started. The affected villages got to know only when they started cutting down their trees for the project. A 13 km long tunnel will be constructed for this project and it will run under 26 villages.
  • The tunnel of the Vishnuprayag Hydroelectric Project (400 MW) is 16 km long and extends between Lambagad and Chaain villages. Four tunnels of this project go from under Chaain village to the power house. In September/October 2007, unexpectedly, land started collapsing and sinking in and around this village.
  • During the construction of the tunnel for this project five natural water sources in the village of Chaain had dried up. A 1 km long irrigation channel that supplied water to the village has become redundant.

Information sourced from the report – Damming Northeast India **
  •  In a study in 2001, 168 hydro power projects were identified in the Brahmaputra basin with a total installed capacity of 63,328 MW. Till October 2010, the government of Arunachal Pradesh had already allotted 132 projects to companies in private and public sector for a total installed capacity of 40,140.5 MW. Around 120 of these involve agreement with private players accompanied by huge monetary advances.
  • Environmental Impact Assessment (EIAs) necessary to approve any power projects have been a farce in India and so it is in the case of NE.  For example - the EIA for the 1,000 MW Siyom project lists 5 bird species in an area which has over 300 species and even in this short list has one which is non-existent; the EIA for the 600 MW Kameng project reclassifies carnivores such as the red panda, pangolins and porcupines as herbivores; the EIA for the 2,000 MW Lower Subansiri lists 55 species of fish in a river which has at least 156 species and reports an area called the ‘Arctic’ in the Eastern Himalayas.
  • Virtually all available arable land in the affected Siang valley will be submerged by the 2700MW Lower Siang project.
  • States like Arunachal Pradesh and Sikkim are home to small populations of culturally sensitive indigenous communities. The entire population of Idu Mishmi tribe in Dibang valley is 9500 and their displacement by 17 projects has been termed as ‘small’. Moreover, the projects will bring in more than 150,000 labourers from outside for a long time which will completely change the demographic and socio-cultural identity of the region.

Damming all the rivers in the bio-diversity hotspot of Arunachal

Soon Teesta and Rangeet will stop being free-flowing rivers

Information sourced from Down to Earth ***
  • A study of 132 dams out of 292 that were proposed or were under construction in 2005, showed that there would be one reservoir every 3000 sqkm which is 62 times the global dam density.
  • 90% of the river valleys and 25% of dense forests in the Indian Himalayas would be affected. Over 54,117 hectares of forests would get submerged while 114,361 hectares would be damaged by dam related activities.
  • 88% of the projects fall in zones rich in plant, bird, fish and butterfly species.

It surprises me immensely that nobody has found it imperative to do a cumulative impact study of more than 600 dams and other projects on the Himalayan eco-system. I am even more surprised that by virtue of being in the Himalayas, these States which should be much more responsible to its people, the rest of the country and the world are hell bent on destroying the future. When will somebody, anybody wake up from slumber and realize that the Himalayas are special, an absolute necessity for our survival and that we need to treat them, its lovely communities and its eco-system differently?

Just when will they let my beloved mountains be before it’s all too late?


The Energy State and the Tragedy of its Rivers - Suresh Bhai; Raksha Sutra Andolan, Jal Sanskriti Manch, Nadi Bachao Andolan Uttarkashi, Himalaya Seva Sangh; Uttarkashi, 2009.

 Damming Northeast India – Joint report by Neeraj Vagholikar (Kalpavriksh), Partha J. Das (Aaryanak) and Action Aid India, 2010.

Himalayan Destruction – Down to Earth, January 2013

Maps – Sanctuary Asia, maps adapted from the Department of Hydropower Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh


  1. grim reading :(

    What can I do? Can I file an RTI petition asking what environmental clearances were obtained before setting in motion this Himalayan chain reaction? You know, for each project.

    1. Abhiroop....the NGOs working on the issue have already done that. its not so simple. the thing is that everything is deeply entrenched with politics and money. and both the politicians and private companies have so much power to ensure that work continues unabated. how else do you think Uttrakhand govt managed to not leak a single report in national media despite so much of protests by the local communities (before the flood ie). I guess...the best solution for all of us is to extend our support as much as possible to these NGOs and local movements.

      Bipasha M

    2. Right, right. Need to make more money!

      I did not mean to sound like some action hero who'd drop in from nowhere and fix everything in a jiffy with his 'unique ideas' :)

    3. hahaha.....but you never knows what just might work and when :-) :-)

      Bipasha M

  2. I wish we could get these these babas and matas to start preaching the environment to people. Savvy marketers, they can really pull some crowds in and make the otherwise tight-fisted folks open their wallets.

    Messages like: contribute 1001/- every month to WWF to help protect Sherawali Mata's precious ride and receive her blessings. Or else your daughter/wife/mom will elope with the hippie from Israel. Kick the puppy and your son/secret gay lover will grow as many nipples as the puppy's mom; so don't. Switch that AC off lest Vayuputra Hanuman pulls a Lanka on your office. Cut that tree and the Naked Fakir of Pedistan will uproot your business from the face of this Earth and Fatwafy the next 17 generations of your family to be born with wooden stumps in place of feet. Carry your trash home in a little travel-trash bag instead of littering and Santoshi Ma will bless your useless progeny with 1 working brain cell for every piece of litter you didn't make. Stop producing further idiot children and lo! Ganesha will banish forever the rats that gnaw your daughter's demented bhangra-popstar tee shirts...

  3. Depressing...

    As you say, the mountains will continue to be -- it will only be too late one day for us humans.

    1. yes parmanu....and what i have mentioned here is just a tip of the iceberg. if the states get to implement what they are planning....then we are doomed. check mail. am sending you some links.

      Bipasha M